Your advanced alert for this should definitely be working the same as the basic alert. Are you monitoring the node status in both the basic and advanced alert or is it the interface that you're monitoring? Would it be possible to post a screenshot of the advanced alert trigger condition?
This is still an issue.
The alert trigger just says alert me when a Node Status is equal to down and Node Status is not equal to unmanaged. There are no Alert Suppression entries. It is set to trigger immediately.
I have Basic Alerts off right now because our Trigger Actions for the Advanced Alert are needed, but I am concerned that for short outages that show as a host down then a host up in the Basic Alerts is not triggering in Advanced Alerts.